Privacy, Security, Luxury

Casey Key Homes For Sale

Casey Key is a beautiful barrier island located on the Gulf Coast of Florida, known for its pristine beaches and luxurious waterfront properties. This exclusive and upscale community offers a serene and secluded escape for residents and visitors alike. Its unique charm is characterized by lush tropical vegetation, stunning sunsets, and a relaxed, laid-back atmosphere. Casey Key is a hidden gem that provides a tranquil retreat for those seeking a more private and upscale beach experience in Florida.

Casey Key Real Estate Statistics

Average Price $3.6M
Lowest Price $6.5K
Highest Price $12.5M
Total Listings 37
Avg. Days On Market 395
Avg. Price/SQFT $1.2K

Property Types (active listings)

Casey Key Homes For Sale


Casey Key Community Lifestyle

Casey Key

The Casey Key lifestyle embodies a unique blend of exclusivity, tranquility, and natural beauty. Living on this barrier island offers residents and visitors an unparalleled experience. Life here is defined by a slower, more relaxed pace, where the soothing sound of the Gulf of Mexico waves and the scent of salty sea air are constants in the background.

Casey Key is a haven for those who seek a refined yet unpretentious way of life. The island is known for its luxurious waterfront properties, each with its own distinctive charm. Whether it's an opulent beachfront mansion or a quaint beach cottage, the architecture complements the island's lush tropical landscape. Residents often engage in water-based activities, from boating and paddleboarding to simply strolling along the pristine shoreline at sunset.

Dining options are a testament to Casey Key's upscale character. While the island itself has limited dining establishments, residents can easily venture to nearby Siesta Key or Venice, where gourmet restaurants and charming cafes await. The sense of community is strong, with regular gatherings, and the close-knit atmosphere is further nurtured by the island's conservation efforts, ensuring the preservation of its natural beauty. In essence, Casey Key offers a lifestyle that blends the tranquility of an island retreat with the exclusivity of an affluent community, creating an idyllic haven for those who choose to call it home.

Casey Key Real Estate

Private Gulf-to-Bay Lifestyle

Casey Real Estate

Casey Key's real estate market is synonymous with exclusivity and opulence. The island is home to some of the most prestigious and sought-after properties on Florida's Gulf Coast. Waterfront homes, from elegant beachfront estates to charming canal-side cottages, offer residents the rare opportunity to wake up to breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico or the Intracoastal Waterway.

The real estate market on Casey Key is characterized by a limited supply of available properties, which adds to its desirability. Residents and investors are drawn to the island's privacy and its reputation for upscale living. Casey Key's real estate values reflect its premium location and idyllic surroundings, making it a prime destination for those seeking a luxurious coastal lifestyle in Southwest Florida. Whether it's a grand mansion with its own stretch of sandy beach or a cozy retreat tucked amid lush tropical vegetation, Casey Key real estate presents a variety of options to cater to the diverse tastes and desires of its discerning clientele.

Casey Key Boating

Boater's Paradise

Casey Key Waterfront

Casey Key offers a boating experience like no other on Florida's Gulf Coast. Boating enthusiasts are drawn to the pristine waters surrounding the island, where they can navigate the Intracoastal Waterway, the Gulf of Mexico, and the nearby bays and estuaries. The island's exclusive waterfront properties often feature private docks, making it convenient for residents to launch their vessels and explore the scenic waterways.

Boaters on Casey Key revel in the stunning natural beauty that surrounds them. The crystal-clear, azure waters are perfect for leisurely cruises, water sports, and fishing expeditions. Whether you're in the mood for a relaxing day of sunbathing on your boat or eager to explore hidden coves and remote islands, the boating lifestyle on Casey Key caters to all preferences. Additionally, the island's close proximity to popular boating destinations like Sarasota and Venice provides ample opportunities for adventurous day trips and waterfront dining experiences, enhancing the allure of Casey Key as a boater's paradise.

Casey Key Real Estate Property Overview
Casey Key Community Info:
Length of Key: 8 miles
Developed: 1950s - Present
Gated: No
Gulf-to-Bay Lots: Yes
Public Beaches: Yes
Golf Course: No
Closest Airport: SRQ
Beachfront: Yes
Min. Lease: 1-month
# of Leases/yr: 12

Casey Key

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Casey Key, Florida, special?

Casey Key is renowned for its pristine beaches, exclusive real estate, and natural beauty. It's a tranquil and luxurious barrier island offering a quiet escape from the bustling Florida mainland.

Is Casey Key open to the public, or is it a private community?

Casey Key is primarily a private residential community. However, there are a few public beach access points for visitors to enjoy its beaches and beautiful scenery.

What activities are popular on Casey Key?

Residents and visitors often enjoy activities such as sunbathing, swimming, fishing, and birdwatching. The island's laid-back atmosphere makes it an ideal place for relaxation and taking in the natural surroundings.

Are there any upscale dining options on Casey Key?

While the island itself has limited dining options, you'll find several upscale restaurants and eateries on nearby Sarasota, Siesta Key and Venice - just a short drive away.

We're On Your Side

Walter Group Real Estate

Our brand promise is to engage our clients with intelligence, candor, and goodwill in every transaction.

Call Me. I'm ready to talk.

Longboat Key Real Estate Search

Walter Group Real Estate - We're on your side

Our mission is to help you achieve your Sarasota Islands' Real Estate Goals. Our brand promise is to engage our clients with intelligence, candor and goodwill in every transaction

About Walter Group Real Estate